Is Uranus a Benefic or Malefic?

PrometheusIf astrologers are divided about Neptune, then they’re REALLY divided about Uranus. Uranus is about sudden change. Uranus is unfettered progress. It seeks to overthrow the existing order at all costs. And that, as we know, can be a pretty iffy situation. So which is it? Is Uranus benefic or malefic?

As always, myth is here to help. However, despite the name, our Uranus has almost nothing to do with Ouranos, the primordial sky god. Instead, the Uranus we know (and love?) is much more closely associated with Prometheus.


Prometheus took the assignment with joy. When Jupiter, king of the gods, had tasked him with creating humanity, Prometheus could hardly contain his excitement. Sure, Jupiter had asked for this mainly because he wanted to create lesser beings to worship and sacrifice to him. He basically wanted little adoration machines. But Prometheus had better plans.

So Prometheus set out to mold humanity from clay. He gave them pious hearts just as Jupiter had commanded. But he also gave them minds – minds that could be critical of the gods and of the established order. He gave them families and vocations and love and all the things that make life worth living. He wanted his little creations to thrive.

Jupiter, for his part, was irritated with the little extras Prometheus had thrown in, but decided that as long as humanity continued to sacrifice all their livestock to him, he would tolerate them.

But this bothered Prometheus. Looking down upon his little people, he noticed they were thin. Gaunt, even. They were starving, but it was nothing a little meat couldn’t fix. So Prometheus hatched a plan.

He gathered up the parts of a bull and divided them onto two plates. On one, he placed an old, spotted liver stuffed full of prime beef. On the other, he placed a bone, which he wrapped up in rich, delicious fat. And then he sped off to Olympus, a grin on his face.

“Great Jupiter, King of Olympus on high, please heed my words. Humanity is starving. The sacrifices we receive are too much for them to give. In order to preserve the human race, and therefore our continued worship, it is only fair that we share each animal with them.”

Jupiter, frustrated but amenable, agreed. The last thing he wanted was to lose all his wonderful sacrifices. Even so, he looked at Prometheus with skepticism.

“I will agree to your request, but why have you brought these two plates? One is most certainly better than the other.”

“Yes,” Prometheus replied, “they are clearly not equal. But far be it from me to deprive the Great God of his choice. I make no assumptions, but instead present these options to you for Your Holiness to choose.”

And Jupiter, gazing upon the offerings, pointed to the one dripping with lush, tempting fat.

Prometheus smiled wide and said, “So it is. Humans will sacrifice bone, entrails, and gristle to the gods. They shall keep the prime meat! How generous of you, my king.”

Jupiter, realizing the trick, flew into a blind rage. Not only had Prometheus failed to respect his office, he took away the best sacrifices, which were the whole reason Jupiter wanted humanity created in the first place, AND Prometheus successfully subverted Jupiter’s omniscience. This. Could. Not. Stand.

Jupiter raised himself and bellowed, “Your love for humanity has blinded you, titan! But now humanity will be as blind as you are. I hereby confiscate fire from earth. May you all stumble in darkness.”

Back down on earth, Prometheus saw the chaos. Humanity couldn’t cook, couldn’t light the night, couldn’t keep predators at bay. If something wasn’t done, the entire species would perish.

Prometheus needed to think. As the god of forethought, he knew exactly what needed to happen. He also knew exactly what consequences he would face. But looking down at the plight of his pitiable children, he steeled himself for his last mission.

Cloaking himself in darkness, he stole up to Olympus while the gods were sleeping. He took a stalk of fennel and slowly lifted it to one of the blazing sconces lighting Jupiter’s palace. As soon as it was alight, he fled to earth and shared his bounty with humanity. Once again, they were saved.

But his joy didn’t last long. As he’d already known would happen, Jupiter discovered his theft. This time his rage could not be contained. Drawing up every ounce of his power as King of Heaven, he flung Prometheus onto a jagged rock jutting out over the ocean and bound him there. He then called one of his eagles and commanded it to devour Prometheus’s liver as a reminder of the organ in which he had hidden Jupiter’s rightful sacrifice. Prometheus took a deep breath and nodded. Off in the distance, he saw humanity dancing in firelight. He had done the right thing.


So is Uranus benefic or malefic? It depends on who you’re talking to. Uranus is an equalizer, willing to put himself on the king’s bad side in order to help the little guy. Because, as anyone who has had a disappointing or even painful Jupiter transit knows, Jupiter gives his gifts selectively. But Uranus loves every person with equal ardor. If there is a structure in our lives that doesn’t serve us, no matter how shiny it looks on the outside, Uranus shakes it away to make room for something better. And where there is power being misused, Uranus is there to knock it down.

Radical change isn’t easy. I’m sure humanity had quite the case of emotional whiplash as Prometheus attempted to secure their fate. And certainly Jupiter was none too pleased. But in the end, humanity thrived because Prometheus was willing to turn the world upside down to make it happen. And that seems pretty benefic to me.

Have you ever been helped by Uranus? Has your world been totally shaken? Tell us the story!

9 thoughts on “Is Uranus a Benefic or Malefic?”

  1. I often shake things up and get into trouble for it. Always a new idea in order to make things better.

    (I’m a Virgo with a ridiculous amount of Uranian/Aquarian signatures in my birth chart)

  2. Hahaha! As Aquarius Rising, my entire life has been a shake up ever so often. One thing I can count on is that nothing is permanent when it comes to my life. Strange things will take place to make sure I stay shook up. Using the old Placidus chart, Saturn is in my 3rd house and Uranus is in my 8th. Now going by the Equal chart the only change here is Saturn falls in my 4th house. But Uranus does a number on me. In my twenties I got electrocuted by our cooking stove and my brother told me that if that current had not of arced away from my heart, it would have killed me.

    Thing is I have 5 Mercury ruled planets along with my Aquarius AC. Uranus is the higher octave of Mercury. I have an abundance of nervous energy that gets supercharged by Uranus and I get zapped frequently, either electrically or by life events.

  3. I have Uranus in Sag 8H. It’s quite a combo of a position, considering I have Moon/Chiron in Gemini, though not in orb, it hurts to be awakened via those specific houses as it carries very real material/mundane repercussions. But, Uranus is also in mutual reception with Jupiter no less, via a sextile by 3deg in Aqu.
    What can I say, it hurts but it opens doors to some things bigger/bolder/truer… Case to say, if I take away wounds/emotions, i can clearly see the wood for the trees…

  4. The other story where Uranus is castrated by Saturn is useful as well in helping us understand the aversion and reactivity Uranian types carry for Saturn.

    1. Ive been around some 1988 saturn conj uranus characters…
      – in early cap, both planets rx, a taurus male I almost married… they conj in his 1H.
      – in early cap (ur) late sag (sat), both direct, a scorpio female frennemy. they conj in her 8H.
      – in late sag, both rx, in exact conj, a cancer male who is my new flatmate
      I don’t know which house the cancer character has the conjunction and we just met, but he seems to have this castrated signature/aura as well. I see the planets in rx as a self-defeating act, as on the Icarus myth: they go too far and karma catches up…
      As for the female with the direct planets, it’s in her natural house, I guess she is more the type of making a good juice out of lemons. She went too far with me and used me for her purposes, so I’m amputating the friendship as well.

      1. The sat/uranus rx conj people seem to really feel like there is something utterly wrong with them. They seem to feel less than, handicapped in some way to deal with real life. But of course we’d have to look to other aspects in the chart, and the 3 people I mention have other common aspects between charts as they’re all born around the same time. But I stand by the Icarus myth regarding this particular aspect.

  5. I have uranus/ saturn in mutual reception in the 1st and semi-sextile and I am not fully in favor of tradition over innovation or the other way around. I have issues with electricity and appliances, this aquarius told me she loved having me around because something was surely gonna happen, not a single boring moment since I always do s o m e t h i n g. Happy accidents.

  6. Thank you, Midara, for you excellent description of the Promethean story. Just going by Uranus and Jupiter’s part in it as you described it, it seems clear to me that all, um, results of engines of experience have both positive and negative expressions in the physical life of all living beings. I, for one, have within my Gemini first house Uranus and Mars only minutes apart. As a sensitive, that gave me a very active imagination, Jupiter, with unexpected shifts in direction, Uranus, that filled my play as a child and fills my experience as an adult. The only way I have been able to dodge Prometheus’ fate is to lean into Jupiter and create what I desire, knowing full well that, whether I create what I desire or just let Life happen to and around me, Uranus will stick itself into it wit unexpected fast and sharp turns where something will peck at my liver if I don’t deal with them. Any success I have had and continue to have protecting my liver is due on my part to constant experimentation, retrograde Mercury at 0 degrees Virgo at my natal Nadir, and unhesitant, Sun sextile Mars, sacrifice to Jupiter where needed, preferring to do that rather than give up any of my liver.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Scroll to Top